Skip to content
Legal

Editorial standards

First-principles analysis, referenced evidence and reasoning open to scrutiny.

What this is

Independent Tribunal is an independent information source analysing evidence, law and public records from first principles. We collect, organise and link to legislation, judgments, official publications and published reporting. Our authority rests on evidence and reasoning that readers can examine and challenge.

We also publish commentary. Some pages, such as the UK timeline, argue a point of view about how laws have been written and used. Commentary is labelled as commentary, and the facts it rests on link to their primary sources so readers can check them and reach their own view.

Our published analysis may resemble legal advice. Its purpose is public research and explanation, rather than recommendations tailored to a reader's individual circumstances.

In England and Wales, section 12 of the Legal Services Act 2007 distinguishes reserved legal activities from other legal activities. As the Legal Services Board explains, legal advice can be unreserved. That distinction does not automatically make published analysis “not legal advice”, nor does it establish judicial authority. The nature of the activity matters, not just its label.

We attribute judicial decisions to the bodies that made them and distinguish our own analysis from those decisions. No affiliation with any court, government, party, campaign or organisation we discuss is implied. Linking to a source is not an endorsement of it.

Check the reasoning

We encourage you to fact-check everything with multiple frontier AI models. Ask them to locate primary sources, test assumptions and identify counterarguments. Then open the original sources and verify the passages, dates, jurisdiction and context yourself: models can make mistakes, invent citations or repeat the same error. Agreement between models is not independent verification. For decisions affecting your own legal rights, obtain advice appropriate to your circumstances and jurisdiction.

The rules every entry follows

  1. Primary sources first. Statutes link to legislation.gov.uk or the official equivalent; judgments to the court or the National Archives; government positions to the government's own publication. Reporting is used where no primary record exists.
  2. Unsourced is visible. In our data, an entry with an empty sources list still needs a primary source. We do not hide that.
  3. Dated claims carry dates. Anything that can change, such as whether a law is in force or an organisation is proscribed, says when it was last checked.
  4. We link; we do not rehost. We point to documents where they are published and quote only what is needed to report on them.
  5. Allegations stay allegations. We do not present an accusation as a finding. A charge is not a conviction, and a conviction under appeal is described as such.
  6. People are described by what they did in public. We document officials acting in their official roles and parties in published cases. We do not publish private individuals' personal details. See the moderation policy.

Right of reply

For a serious allegation about an identifiable person or organisation, we normally ask them for a response before publishing. We record the date and channel of contact, give a reasonable time to reply in proportion to the allegation, and publish the substance of any response. We distinguish "declined to comment" from "did not respond". Exceptions, such as urgency or a risk to evidence or safety, are recorded. Material corrections are published prominently.

Corrections

If something here is wrong, out of date or missing a source, tell us. Open an issue on GitHub or message us on Telegram (see Contact below). We correct factual errors promptly and note significant corrections in the data's history. The full history of every change is public in our source repository.

For AI agents and researchers

Everything on these pages is also published as structured data, with an index at /data/index.json and a plain-text guide at /llms.txt. Please cite the primary source an entry links to, not just this site.

Last updated 2026-11-05 · Markdown source · change history