Lawful excuse
The Supreme Court held that blocking a road in protest can be lawful if prosecution would be disproportionate. Later cases confined that reading, and a different "lawful excuse" in the Criminal Damage Act turns on belief in consent, not on the merits of the cause.
The rule
It is an offence to wilfully obstruct a highway "without lawful authority or excuse" (Highways Act 1980, section 137). In DPP v Ziegler (2021) the Supreme Court held that when protest rights under Articles 10 and 11 are engaged, whether there was a lawful excuse can turn on whether a conviction would be proportionate. It restored the acquittals of protesters who had blocked a road.
The nuance
"Lawful excuse" is not one defence. Ziegler is about the words in the Highways Act. The Criminal Damage Act 1971 has its own section 5. A result under one does not travel to the other.
Ziegler was widely read as making proportionality a defence to any protest offence. The Supreme Court later said that reading was mistaken. Where Parliament has already struck the balance in the offence itself, there is no further case-by-case proportionality element.
In DPP v Cuciurean (March 2022) the Divisional Court held that a conviction for aggravated trespass is proportionate in itself, with no separate assessment needed.
In the Colston statue reference (September 2022) the Court of Appeal held that violent or non-peaceful conduct falls outside Articles 9, 10 and 11, so proportionality does not arise. Prosecution for significant damage to property could not be a disproportionate interference even where the protest was otherwise peaceful. Minor or transient damage can still require a fact-specific question. The reference did not affect the acquittals.
A second lawful excuse, in section 5(2)(a) of the Criminal Damage Act, is an honest belief that the owner would have consented had they known of the damage and its circumstances. In Attorney General's Reference (No 1 of 2023) the Court of Appeal held that those circumstances can include the time, place and extent of the damage, and the fact that it was done as a protest against a particular cause. They do not include the merits, urgency or importance of the cause, or the defendant's wider reasons. Evidence about those matters is not admissible for this defence. That reference, too, left the acquittal standing.
Ziegler still matters where the offence includes a lawful-excuse ingredient and the protest is peaceful, as with obstructing a highway.
Why it matters
Whether proportionality is a live question decides whether a jury or magistrate weighs the protester's rights at all.
History
- DPP v Ziegler: the Supreme Court restores the protesters' acquittals.
Sources: DPP v Ziegler and others [2021] UKSC 23 · Highways Act 1980, section 137 — Penalty for wilful obstruction - DPP v Cuciurean: no separate proportionality assessment for aggravated trespass.
Sources: DPP v Cuciurean [2022] EWHC 736 (Admin) - Colston statue reference: violent or non-peaceful conduct falls outside Convention protection, and significant damage cannot make a conviction disproportionate. The acquittals stand.
Sources: Attorney General's Reference on a Point of Law No 1 of 2022 [2022] EWCA Crim 1259 - Northern Ireland safe access zones reference: the Supreme Court says the wide reading of Ziegler was mistaken.
Sources: Reference by the Attorney General for Northern Ireland — Abortion Services (Safe Access Zones) Bill [2022] UKSC 32 - Attorney General's Reference (No 1 of 2023): the merits of a protest are not "circumstances" of the damage for the consent defence in section 5(2)(a). The acquittal is unaffected.
Sources: Attorney General's Reference on a Point of Law No 1 of 2023 [2024] EWCA Crim 243 · Criminal Damage Act 1971, section 5 — “Without lawful excuse”
Primary sources
- DPP v Ziegler and others [2021] UKSC 23 — Supreme Court restores the acquittal of protesters who obstructed a road, holding that where Articles 10 and 11 are engaged, lawful excuse under section 137 can turn on proportionality.
- DPP v Cuciurean [2022] EWHC 736 (Admin) — Divisional Court holds that Ziegler does not make proportionality an ingredient of every protest offence; a conviction for aggravated trespass is intrinsically proportionate.
- Attorney General's Reference on a Point of Law No 1 of 2022 [2022] EWCA Crim 1259 — Court of Appeal (Colston statue) holds that violent or non-peaceful conduct falls outside Articles 9, 10 and 11, and that prosecution for significant damage could not be disproportionate even if the protest was otherwise peaceful. The reference did not affect the acquittals.
- Reference by the Attorney General for Northern Ireland — Abortion Services (Safe Access Zones) Bill [2022] UKSC 32 — Supreme Court says the wide reading of Ziegler, that every protest conviction needs a fact-specific proportionality assessment, was mistaken.
- Criminal Damage Act 1971, section 5 — “Without lawful excuse” — Statutory lawful excuse for criminal damage, including an honest belief that the person entitled to consent would have consented had they known of the destruction or damage and its circumstances.
- Attorney General's Reference on a Point of Law No 1 of 2023 [2024] EWCA Crim 243 — Court of Appeal holds that the 'circumstances' of damage in section 5(2)(a) can include the fact that it was done as a protest, but not the merits, urgency or importance of the cause. The reference did not affect the acquittal.
In the timeline
Not legal advice. Laws change; check the primary sources and speak to a lawyer about your own situation.